Controversial Approval of 13-Bed HMO in Scarborough South Bay

Local councillors approved a plan to change an old bed and breakfast into a 13-bed house in multiple occupation (HMO) at 7 Blands Cliff, Scarborough. Councillors met on Thursday, December 12, 2023, and split their votes. One side saw more housing for the community; the other side feared harm for the town.

Community Concerns

More than 30 residents spoke out. They worried that the new HMO might bring in temporary residents and cause unrest in the area. Some pointed to Scarborough’s struggle with housing since the town already has 120 HMOs with over a thousand beds. Local resident Tony Fencer asked, “Are you going to Scarborough Fair? Or to Scarborough, the HMO capital of North Yorkshire?” His words matched the thoughts of others. They said that Blands Cliff is an important route to South Bay Beach. Visitors come to that beach, and a crowded street might spoil the town’s feel.

Planning Authority’s Initial Hesitations

At first, the planning authority had doubts over the plan. They worried about living space issues, waste management, and whether the place would run well. The original plan had 14 bedrooms. After talks, that number dropped to 13, and the applicant promised a management plan. A council report said the HMO would have more space than the minimum and include three kitchens. The plan tried to deal with worries about crowded rooms.

Perspectives on the HMO Benefits

John McDermott, the agent for the plan, said HMOs help people find homes they can afford. He said, “HMOs do not bring harm; they are an important part of housing here. They allow young people to leave home and live on their own. They also help workers find a place nearby.”
Councillor Janet Jefferson did not agree. She worried about the future and wished instead to see self-contained flats. She thought the change would help investors earn more rent, but she did not see gains for the local area.

Some councillors saw a clear need for more affordable housing, especially for young people. Councillor Subash Sharma said the town must attract young people so that the local workforce can grow. He noted that most young people could not buy a home by themselves.

Final Decision

In the end, the Scarborough and Whitby Area Planning Committee approved the plan under conditions. The chair used a casting vote to do so. This choice marks an important moment in the town’s housing debate and raises new questions. Community members now wonder how to balance enough housing with a strong local identity.

Summary

The plan for a 13-bed HMO in Scarborough’s South Bay has caused strong debate. Supporters stress the need for affordable homes for young people. Others fear the plan may hurt community life and the town’s welcome to visitors. This case shows the hard choices in today’s housing market and the need to balance growth with a healthy neighborhood.

For further insights on property investment and housing in the UK, check out The Guardian and BBC News.

Sources

• Scarborough Planning Authority Reports
• Local Resident Testimonials
• Official Councillor Statements at Planning Meeting
• The Guardian
• BBC News