Controversial Approval for 13-Bed HMO at Blands Cliff: Balancing Community Needs and Housing Demands in Scarborough

Approval for 13-Bed HMO at Blands Cliff, Scarborough: A Mixed Response from Residents

North Yorkshire County Council approved a plan on December 12. The plan changes a three-storey former bed and breakfast at 7 Blands Cliff into a 13-bed house shared by many occupants. Many residents opposed the plan as shown at the meeting.

Community Concerns Over Development

Over 30 residents spoke against the plan. They worry about more antisocial behavior when more people come and go. One resident, Tony Fencer, noted that Scarborough already holds about 120 shared houses with over a thousand beds. He asked, "How can adding another house cause no harm to tourism when our town relies on visitors?" His question captured many residents’ fears.

Planning Committee’s Thoughts

The planning panel raised questions on living quality, waste handling, and the upkeep of the property. The applicant cut the number of beds from 14 to 13. The applicant gave a plan for running the house and made some firm promises. These changes helped win some votes.
John McDermott, the agent for the plan, said houses like these help many first-time renters and serve local workers by giving them a place to stay.

Divided Opinions Among Councillors

The council did not all agree with the plan. Councillor Janet Jefferson, who serves the Castle ward, argued that changing the building into flats would help both the area and the developer. In contrast, Councillor Subash Sharma stressed that young people need affordable homes. He said, "We need young people here to work and help our community, as many cannot buy a flat."

Moving Forward: What This Means for Scarborough

The chair used a casting vote to pass the plan. This result shows the divide between people who worry about local harm and the need for more homes. Scarborough faces pressures where rental homes are scarce, and many seek affordable living spaces.
This new house fits a rising trend where shared houses are used to meet housing shortages, especially for young people and workers moving here. Still, local life and the town’s appeal to visitors face risks.

Conclusion

The 13-bed plan at Blands Cliff meets the need for more housing in Scarborough. At the same time, it highlights concerns about local impacts and visitor numbers. As new projects start, local leaders and community members must talk to work out a future that suits everyone.

For ongoing updates on housing and development in Scarborough, consider subscribing to local news platforms and following trustworthy resources online.